Listing № 87407 · Youngstown, OH
The Coin Shop of Youngstown
Coin shop in Youngstown, Ohio
5130 Youngstown-Poland Rd, Youngstown, OH 44514
Photos from The Coin Shop of Youngstown's website
Photos from the dealer's website · Scroll for more
Good for: First-time sellers · Buying bullion
§ 01
What The Coin Shop of Youngstown buys and does
§ 02
What recent customers report
We read the 60 most recent public Google reviews (Apr 2021 – Sep 2026) and counted what they mention. We don't republish reviews. Read them on Google ↗
- Recent rating
- 4.8★
- last 60 reviews
- Reviews, past 12 months
- 16
- busy shop
- Owner replies
- 65%
- 2 of 3 one- or two-star
- Fair-offer mentions
- 96%
- 22 fair vs 1 lowball
Praised for
- Friendly, welcoming25 of 43
- Fair offers / fair prices18 of 43
- Honest, trustworthy13 of 43
- Knowledgeable13 of 43
- Explained the process8 of 43
- Reasonable premiums when buying6 of 43
Complaints
- Lowball offers1 of 43
What people brought in
- Silver Eagles & rounds ×2
Sold coins or metal (8) · Bought coins or bullion (4) · Got an appraisal (2)
2 reviewers were first-time sellers or inheritors. 5 say they compared offers and got the best one here.
§ 03
Trust record
Better Business Bureau
No BBB profile found for this business. That's common for small shops and isn't a red flag on its own.
Credentials & licenses
- Ohio Precious Metals Dealer license (PRECIOUS METALS DEALER) #PM.300682.000 · Active (on current DFI roster) registry ↗
Named by local collectors
- Recommended in r/Cleveland (2023)
§ 04
Before you sell here
- 1
Know your metal floor before you walk in.
Gold is — and silver — an ounce right now. Our offer checker shows what your coins are worth in metal and whether an offer is fair.
- 2
Bring a government photo ID.
Yes - bring identification. A licensed precious metals dealer must record your name, age, residence, driver's license number or other personal ID, and a short physical description (ORC 4728.06).
A licensed dealer must keep each item it buys in Ohio until 5 days after the purchase (ORC 4728.09(A)).
Source: ORC 4728.06 - Records (seller name, age, residence, ID number, physical description), ORC 4728.07 - Daily report of items received to police department · All Ohio rules
- 3
Call ahead for anything bigger than a few coins.
Ask whether the person who prices collections is in that day, and whether they pay by cash or check for larger amounts.
- 4
Get a second offer.
There are 3 other coin buyers within 10 miles — compare them below. Read how to sell a coin collection first if this is your first time.
Questions to ask The Coin Shop of Youngstown
We couldn't confirm these from public sources, so ask before you go:
- What would you pay today for a 1 oz American Silver Eagle, and for $1 face value of pre-1965 silver? (Ask two shops the same question to compare.)
- Is an appraisal free, or free only if I sell to you? Do you put it in writing?
- How do you pay for larger amounts — cash, check or wire — and is there a cash limit?
- Do I need an appointment to sell a whole collection?
§ 05
Compare coin buyers near Youngstown
If this shop isn't the right fit
- Nearest open on Sunday: Ohio Trading Coin & Jewelry~35 mi
- Nearest open Saturday: Boardman Coin & Jewelry - Boardman~2.5 mi
- Nearest NGC-authorized dealer: Elite Rare Coins~20 mi
- Nearest that buys estates: Golden Dreams Jewelers~38 mi
| Dealer | Type | Distance | Fair-offer mentions | Sat / Sun | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| The Coin Shop of Youngstown (this shop) | Coin shop | — | 4.9★ (120) | 96% | – / – |
| Boardman Coin & Jewelry - BoardmanYoungstown | Gold & silver buyer | 2.5 mi | 3.4★ (142) | 29% | Sat / – |
| Treasure Center 1Hubbard | Coin shop | 7.8 mi | 4.7★ (23) | — | Sat / – |
| Hubbard Gold and CoinHubbard | Coin shop | 7.9 mi | 4.3★ (22) | — | – / – |
| Shaffer Rare CoinsNiles | Coin shop | 13 mi | 4.7★ (86) | — | – / – |
| Steel Valley Coin-N-CurrencyBrookfield Township | Coin shop | 13 mi | 4.8★ (55) | — | – / – |
| Boardman Coin Jewelry IncNiles | Gold & silver buyer | 13 mi | 3.9★ (49) | — | Sat / – |
| Mahoning Valley Gold and Silver LLCSalem | Coin shop | 16 mi | 3.2★ (11) | — | – / – |
| Elite Rare CoinsWarren | Bullion dealer | 20 mi | 4.7★ (59) | — | – / – |