Coin shops & coin dealers in Sarasota, Florida
8 hand-verified dealers, ranked by review volume. See who's NGC-authorized, who buys collections, and who specializes in what — before you walk in.
8
Verified dealers
3
NGC-authorized
4.7★
Avg Google rating
293
Google reviews
Filter by what you need
Cash for Gold
1901 S Tamiami Trl D
4.8(119)
(941) 544-8344
Coastal Coin Company
229 S Osprey Ave
4.8(76)
(941) 487-8265
Florida Coins & Stamps
7265 Bee Ridge Rd
4.8(38)
(941) 201-9232
World Coin & Jewelry Exchange
4450 S Tamiami Trl Unit C
4.6(38)
(941) 365-5415
Gold & Silver Refinery
4047 Bee Ridge Rd
4.5(22)
(941) 925-4653
MintBuilder.com LLC
1990 Main Street Suite 750
(941) 298-4994
Sarasota Rare Coin Gallery
640 South Washington Blvd. Suite 100
(941) 366-2191
Stelzer Collectibles
PO BOX 50667
(605) 321-1449
Coin dealers in other Florida cities
Buying & selling coins in Sarasota: common questions
Which Sarasota coin shops are the most established?
Coastal Coin Company has been in business since 1936, making it the oldest name in our Sarasota listings, and it carries a strong review history. This directory lists 8 hand-verified Sarasota dealers in total, three of them NGC-authorized — a high proportion for a city this size.
Where can I sell coins or gold in Sarasota?
Sarasota's Gulf Coast market covers collectibles, bullion, and scrap. Long-running shops like Coastal Coin Company handle numismatic coins, while others focus on cash-for-gold. Because gold offers track the live spot price, check the day's price and get a second quote; our gold melt-value calculator gives you a fast baseline.
Are there NGC-authorized dealers in Sarasota?
Yes — three of the eight hand-verified Sarasota dealers in this directory are NGC-authorized, meaning they meet the grading service's standards for authenticity and business practices. That's a useful shortlist if you're buying or selling higher-grade collectible coins.
How do I know what my coins are worth before visiting a Sarasota dealer?
Separate melt value from collectible value. For bullion and common silver, our silver and gold melt-value calculators give you a live-price baseline in seconds; for rare or graded coins, get quotes from a couple of the hand-verified Sarasota shops here. Two opinions beat one.