№ 01 · Coin shop
Sarasota Rare Coin Gallery
640 South Washington Blvd. Suite 100
- Sells:
- Not verified
- Buys:
- Call to confirm
- Appraisals:
- Not verified
4.5(106 Google)
- BBB A+
- NGC authorized
- PCGS listed
Reviewed this monthOpen Sat
City ledger · Sarasota, FL · updated Oct 2026
Coin shops & coin dealers in Sarasota, FL
11 local listings. Compare buying, selling, appraisals and hours. Compare services & hours ↓
Filters
Choose filters
Showing 11 listings
No shops match all selected filters. Clear filters or remove an option to see more shops.
9 coin shops & bullion dealers
№ 02 · Coin shop · 2.9 mi
Coastal Coin Company
229 S Osprey Ave
- Sells:
- U.S. coins, World coins, Paper money
- Buys:
- U.S. coins, Paper money, World coins, Platinum
- Appraisals:
- Free appraisals
- Visits:
- Walk-ins welcome
4.9(78 Google)
Reviewed last monthOpen Sat
№ 03 · Coin shop · 6.2 mi
Numismatic Guaranty Company
5501 Communications Pkwy
- Sells:
- Not verified
- Buys:
- Call to confirm
- Appraisals:
- Not verified
2.8(50 Google)
- BBB A+
Reviewed last month
№ 04 · Coin & stamp shop · 4.4 mi
Florida Coins & Stamps
7265 Bee Ridge Rd
- Sells:
- U.S. coins, World coins, Bullion, Paper money
- Buys:
- Whole collections, Bullion bars & rounds, U.S. coins, Paper money
- Appraisals:
- Not verified
4.8(42 Google)
- ANA listed
Reviewed 2 months ago
№ 05 · Coin shop · 3.7 mi
U.S. Coin and Jewelry Inc
5900 S Tamiami Trl Ste J
- Sells:
- Not verified
- Buys:
- Call to confirm
- Appraisals:
- Not verified
4.6(40 Google)
Reviewed last month
№ 06 · Coin shop · 2.8 mi
World Coin & Jewelry Exchange
4450 S Tamiami Trl Unit C
- Sells:
- Not verified
- Buys:
- Call to confirm
- Appraisals:
- Not verified
4.6(39 Google)
- BBB A+
Reviewed 3 months agoOpen Sat
№ 07 · Coin shop
AspenRCT/Doug Sharpe
P.O. Box 1708
- Sells:
- Not verified
- Buys:
- Call to confirm
- Appraisals:
- Not verified
- NGC authorized
- PCGS listed
- ANA listed
№ 08 · Appointment-only dealer
MintBuilder.com LLC
1990 Main Street Suite 750
- Sells:
- U.S. coins, World coins, Bullion, Jewelry
- Buys:
- Bullion bars & rounds, Platinum
- Appraisals:
- Not verified
- BBB A+
- NGC authorized
№ 09 · Coin shop
Stelzer Collectibles
PO BOX 50667
- Sells:
- Not verified
- Buys:
- Call to confirm
- Appraisals:
- Not verified
- NGC authorized
Also buy coins: pawn shops, jewelers & gold buyers
Fine for scrap gold, bullion and common silver priced by weight. For anything that might be worth more than its metal, get a coin shop's opinion first.
№ 10 · Gold & silver buyer · 2.2 mi
Cash for Gold
1901 S Tamiami Trl D
- Sells:
- Bullion, Jewelry
- Buys:
- Gold coins, Bullion bars & rounds, Gold jewelry & scrap
- Appraisals:
- Not verified
4.9(154 Google)91% fair-offer mentions
Reviewers sold: Gold jewelry & scrap
Reviewed this monthOpen Sat
№ 11 · Gold & silver buyer · 1.0 mi
Gold & Silver Refinery
4047 Bee Ridge Rd
- Sells:
- Not verified
- Buys:
- Gold coins, Silver coins, Gold jewelry & scrap, Platinum
- Appraisals:
- Not verified
4.4(28 Google)
- BBB A+
Reviewed last month
Sarasota coin-buying overview
- Dedicated coin shops
- 9
- Also buy coins
- 2
- Recent reviews analyzed
- 54
- Fair / low-offer mentions
- 29 / 3
Shortcuts
If you only have a minute
Most-reviewed coin shop
106 Google reviews, 4.5★
Most 'fair offer' mentions
Cash for Gold
29 recent reviews describe fair offers; 3 call them low
Free appraisals
stated on their own websites
Open Saturday
Sarasota Rare Coin Gallery, Coastal Coin Company, World Coin & Jewelry Exchange
4 of 11 open Saturdays
Longest in business
since 2007
NGC / PCGS / PNG listed
Sarasota Rare Coin Gallery, Coastal Coin Company, Numismatic Guaranty Company
found in the grading services' and dealer guild directories
Compare shops
What each Sarasota coin shop offers
Compare buying and selling categories, appraisal options, hours and source records. Services marked unverified need a phone call to confirm. Call for current stock; selling categories come from shop websites.
Filters
Choose filters
| Shop & location | Buying & selling | Appraisals | Hours & visits | Reviews & offers | Records |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Coin shop 640 South Washington Blvd. Suite 100 Call (941) 366-2191 | Sells Not verified Buys Call to confirm | Not verified |
Weekly hours
| 4.5 / 5 on Google · 106 reviews Offer reports not analyzed |
|
Coin shop 229 S Osprey Ave 2.9 mi from city center Call (941) 487-8265 | Sells
Buys
|
| Walk-ins welcome
Weekly hours
| 4.9 / 5 on Google · 78 reviews Offer reports not analyzed | No record verified |
Numismatic Guaranty Company Coin shop 5501 Communications Pkwy 6.2 mi from city center Call (941) 360-3990 | Sells Not verified Buys Call to confirm | Not verified |
Weekly hours
| 2.8 / 5 on Google · 50 reviews Offer reports not analyzed |
|
Coin & stamp shop 7265 Bee Ridge Rd 4.4 mi from city center Call (941) 201-9232 | Sells
Buys
| Not verified |
Weekly hours
| 4.8 / 5 on Google · 42 reviews Offer reports not analyzed |
|
U.S. Coin and Jewelry Inc Coin shop 5900 S Tamiami Trl Ste J 3.7 mi from city center Call (941) 922-0220 | Sells Not verified Buys Call to confirm | Not verified |
Weekly hours
| 4.6 / 5 on Google · 40 reviews Offer reports not analyzed | No record verified |
World Coin & Jewelry Exchange Coin shop 4450 S Tamiami Trl Unit C 2.8 mi from city center Call (941) 365-5415 | Sells Not verified Buys Call to confirm | Not verified |
Weekly hours
| 4.6 / 5 on Google · 39 reviews Offer reports not analyzed |
|
AspenRCT/Doug Sharpe Coin shop P.O. Box 1708 Call (941) 650-8524 | Sells Not verified Buys Call to confirm | Not verified | Hours not verified | Google rating not verified Offer reports not analyzed |
|
Appointment-only dealer 1990 Main Street Suite 750 Call (941) 298-4994 | Sells
Buys
| Not verified | Weekly hours
| Google rating not verified Offer reports not analyzed |
|
Stelzer Collectibles Coin shop PO BOX 50667 Call (605) 321-1449 | Sells Not verified Buys Call to confirm | Not verified | Hours not verified | Google rating not verified Offer reports not analyzed |
|
Cash for Gold Gold & silver buyer 1901 S Tamiami Trl D 2.2 mi from city center Call (941) 544-8344 | Sells
Buys
| Not verified |
Weekly hours
| 4.9 / 5 on Google · 154 reviews 29 fair / 3 low-offer mentions in 54 reviews analyzed | No record verified |
Gold & Silver Refinery Gold & silver buyer 4047 Bee Ridge Rd 1.0 mi from city center Call (941) 925-4653 | Sells Not verified Buys
| Not verified |
Weekly hours
| 4.4 / 5 on Google · 28 reviews Offer reports not analyzed |
|
No shops match all selected filters. Clear filters or remove an option to see more shops.
Offer reports are counts from recent Google review samples, not a guarantee of what a shop will pay. Distance is from the city center.
When can you sell?
How many Sarasota shops are open, hour by hour
| Day | 8a | 9a | 10a | 11a | 12p | 1p | 2p | 3p | 4p | 5p | 6p | 7p |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mon | 1 | 4 | 8 | 9 | 9 | 9 | 9 | 9 | 7 | 2 | · | · |
| Tue | 1 | 4 | 8 | 9 | 9 | 9 | 9 | 9 | 7 | 2 | · | · |
| Wed | 1 | 4 | 8 | 9 | 9 | 9 | 9 | 9 | 7 | 2 | · | · |
| Thu | 1 | 4 | 8 | 9 | 9 | 9 | 9 | 9 | 7 | 2 | · | · |
| Fri | 1 | 3 | 7 | 8 | 8 | 8 | 8 | 8 | 7 | 2 | · | · |
| Sat | · | 1 | 4 | 4 | 4 | 3 | 1 | 1 | · | · | · | · |
| Sun | · | · | · | · | · | · | · | · | · | · | · | · |
None list Sunday hours. None stay open past 6 pm on weekdays. Based on 9 shops with posted hours; hours change, so call ahead.
From 54 recent reviews
What Sarasota sellers bring in, and how it goes
Most-mentioned items
- 1Gold jewelry & scrap2 reviews
The experience, by the numbers
- 16 reviewers: sold coins or metal
- 4 reviewers: got an appraisal
- 3 reviewers: bought coins or bullion
- 26 praise: fair offers / fair prices
- 24 praise: friendly, welcoming
- 15 praise: honest, trustworthy
- 8 praise: good selection
- 3 complain: lowball offers
- 2 complain: rude or dismissive
- Shops reply to 24% of reviews on average
Counted from each shop's most recent public Google reviews. We tally topics; we don't republish reviews.
Florida law
Selling coins in Sarasota: what Florida requires
When you sell
When a walk-in Florida secondhand dealer buys used jewelry, scrap gold or silver, or other secondhand goods from you, state law requires the following: a government-issued photo ID, your right thumbprint, your contact details and physical description, and a signed statement that you own the goods or may sell them. You must be 18 or older.
Walk-in secondhand dealers (s. 538.06(1)): may not sell, alter or otherwise dispose of a precious metal, gemstone, jewelry item, antique or art item for 30 calendar days after acquiring it, or of other secondhand goods for 15 calendar days.
When you buy
Since August 1, 2025, Florida has exempted all sales of gold, silver and platinum bullion regardless of price. Before that, a single transaction was exempt only if it was over $500.
Florida does not tax the sale of coins or currency that are legal tender of the United States, even when they sell above face value or for their metal content. Florida does tax coins that are not legal tender (DOR's rule examples are ancient Roman coins, medieval English coins and Confederate money).
Who licenses dealers
Florida has no license specific to coin dealers (none was found in chs. 212, 538 or 539). A business that sells taxable items, including taxable coins, must register with the Department of Revenue to collect sales tax.
Sources: Chapter 538, Florida Statutes (2026) - Secondhand Dealers and Secondary Metals Recyclers (ss. 538.03, 538.04, 538.06, 538.09, 538.15, 538.17, 538.18, 538.235, 538.31-538.36) · Chapter 539, Florida Statutes (2026) - Florida Pawnbroking Act (s. 539.001; s. 539.002) · FL Department of Revenue - Secondhand Dealers and Secondary Metals Recyclers (local law enforcement enforces recordkeeping and holding periods). Not legal advice. Full Florida rules →
Local collectors
Coin clubs & shows near Sarasota
A coin show puts a dozen dealers in one room — the easiest way to get several offers in an afternoon. Clubs are where to ask who's honest.
State association: Florida United Numismatists, Inc. — 72nd Annual FUN Convention, 2027-01-07 to 2027-01-10
Questions
Selling coins in Sarasota: common questions
How many coin shops are in Sarasota?
We list 11 businesses in Sarasota that buy coins: 9 dedicated coin or bullion shops and 2 pawn shops, jewelers or gold buyers that also buy coins. 4 are NGC-authorized.
Which Sarasota coin shops offer free appraisals?
Coastal Coin Company says on its website that appraisals are free. Call ahead for large collections.
Are any coin shops in Sarasota open on weekends?
4 are open Saturdays (Sarasota Rare Coin Gallery, Coastal Coin Company and World Coin & Jewelry Exchange), and none list Sunday hours. Hours change, so check before you go.
Do I need ID to sell coins in Sarasota?
When a walk-in Florida secondhand dealer buys used jewelry, scrap gold or silver, or other secondhand goods from you, state law requires the following: a government-issued photo ID, your right thumbprint, your contact details and physical description, and a signed statement that you own the goods or may sell them. You must be 18 or older. Walk-in secondhand dealers (s. 538.06(1)): may not sell, alter or otherwise dispose of a precious metal, gemstone, jewelry item, antique or art item for 30 calendar days after acquiring it, or of other secondhand goods for 15 calendar days.
Is there sales tax on gold and silver in Florida?
Since August 1, 2025, Florida has exempted all sales of gold, silver and platinum bullion regardless of price. Before that, a single transaction was exempt only if it was over $500. Florida does not tax the sale of coins or currency that are legal tender of the United States, even when they sell above face value or for their metal content.
Where can I sell coins or gold in Sarasota?
Sarasota's Gulf Coast market covers collectibles, bullion, and scrap. Long-running shops like Coastal Coin Company handle numismatic coins, while others focus on cash-for-gold. Because gold offers track the live spot price, check the day's price and get a second quote; the CoinShop Finder gold melt-value calculator gives you a fast baseline.
Are there NGC-authorized dealers in Sarasota?
Yes — three of the eight hand-verified Sarasota dealers in CoinShop Finder are NGC-authorized, meaning they meet the grading service's standards for authenticity and business practices. That's a useful shortlist if you're buying or selling higher-grade collectible coins.
How do I know what my coins are worth before visiting a Sarasota dealer?
Separate melt value from collectible value. For bullion and common silver, CoinShop Finder silver and gold melt-value calculators give you a live-price baseline in seconds; for rare or graded coins, get quotes from a couple of the hand-verified Sarasota shops here. Two opinions beat one.
Coin shops in nearby cities
- Bradenton12 mi · 6
- Largo45 mi · 7
- Tampa46 mi · 13
- Lakeland60 mi · 4
- Fort Myers65 mi · 10
- Naples87 mi · 5
- Orlando111 mi · 7
- West Palm Beach154 mi · 5
How this page is built: listings come from the NGC dealer locator, Google Maps and our own discovery; services come from each dealer's website; review topics are counted from each shop's most recent public Google reviews; BBB grades from bbb.org. No dealer pays to be listed or ranked. Methodology · Report a problem