GOLD —SILVER —

Melt values →
CoinShop Finder

City ledger · Erie, PA · updated Nov 2026

Coin shops & coin dealers in Erie, PA

6 local listings. Compare buying, selling, appraisals and hours. Compare services & hours ↓

Filters

Choose filters
Shop filters

Shops must match every selected filter.

Showing 6 listings

2 coin shops & bullion dealers

№ 01 · Coin shop · 1.8 mi

PJ Coins & Metals

5152 Old French Rd

Sells:
Not verified
Buys:
Call to confirm
Appraisals:
Not verified
4.8(44 Google)
  • BBB NR

Reviewed last monthOpen Sat

№ 02 · Coin shop · 2.3 mi

Gem City Silver

160 W 8th St

Sells:
Not verified
Buys:
Call to confirm
Appraisals:
Not verified

    Open SatOpen Sun

    Also buy coins: pawn shops, jewelers & gold buyers

    Fine for scrap gold, bullion and common silver priced by weight. For anything that might be worth more than its metal, get a coin shop's opinion first.

    № 03 · Gold & silver buyer · 2.5 mi

    Erie Gold Exchange · W 8th St

    2256 W 8th St

    Sells:
    Bullion, Jewelry
    Buys:
    Estates & inherited coins, Silver coins, Bullion bars & rounds, Gold jewelry & scrap
    Appraisals:
    Free appraisals, Estate / insurance appraisals
    4.9(747 Google)100% fair-offer mentions
    • BBB B-

    Reviewed this monthOpen Sat

    № 04 · Gold & silver buyer · 0.8 mi

    Erie Gold Exchange · Peach St

    5034 Peach St

    Sells:
    U.S. coins, Bullion, Jewelry
    Buys:
    Estates & inherited coins, Silver coins, Bullion bars & rounds, U.S. coins
    Appraisals:
    Free appraisals, Estate / insurance appraisals
    4.9(568 Google)
    • BBB B-

    Reviewed this monthOpen Sat

    № 05 · Jeweler · 2.0 mi

    Dempsey & Baxter

    6032 Peach Street

    Sells:
    U.S. coins, Bullion, Paper money, Jewelry
    Buys:
    U.S. coins
    Appraisals:
    Not verified
    4.8(267 Google)91% fair-offer mentions
    • BBB NR
    • NGC authorized
    • PCGS listed

    Reviewers sold: Gold jewelry & scrap

    Reviewed last month

    Buy gold & silver online

    Can't find it in Erie? Get it shipped

    For standard bullion coins and bars, national online dealers carry far deeper inventory than any one shop, with prices that move with spot all day.

    APMEX

    One of the largest U.S. online bullion dealers, trading for 20+ years with 1M+ customers.

    • Gold & silver coins, bars and rounds
    • Live prices tied to spot
    • Insured shipping to your door
    Shop gold at APMEX

    Bullion Exchanges

    Online precious-metals dealer with a deep catalog of bullion coins and bars.

    • Gold, silver & platinum bullion
    • Government-minted coins and private bars
    • Ships nationwide
    Browse Bullion Exchanges

    About Erie

    Buying and selling coins in Erie

    Erie's gold and coin buyers cluster along Peach Street and West 8th Street. Dempsey & Baxter on Peach Street has operated since 1956, and Erie Gold Exchange since 1982.

    Erie had an estimated 92,940 residents in July 2024 (U.S. Census Bureau), down 2.2% since 2020. That is one dedicated coin or bullion shop for every 46,000 residents, against one per 32,000 across the Pennsylvania cities we list. It ranks tied for 6th among 81 Pennsylvania cities in our directory for dedicated coin shops. Of the places here that buy coins, 33% are dedicated coin or bullion shops; the rest are pawn shops, jewelers and gold buyers. In recent Google reviews of these shops, the items sellers mention most are gold jewelry & scrap. The longest-running listed business, Dempsey & Baxter, dates to 1956. One listed shop is an authorized NGC dealer.

    Residents (2024)
    92,940
    Dedicated coin shops
    2
    Also buy coins
    4
    Recent reviews analyzed
    97

    Population: U.S. Census Bureau, Vintage 2024 city and town population estimates (Erie city). Shop counts are from our listings.

    Shortcuts

    If you only have a minute

    Compare shops

    What each Erie coin shop offers

    Compare buying and selling categories, appraisal options, hours and source records. Services marked unverified need a phone call to confirm. Call for current stock; selling categories come from shop websites.

    Filters

    Choose filters
    Shop filters

    Shops must match every selected filter.

    Coin shops in Erie: buying and selling categories, appraisals, visiting information, reviews and verification
    Shop & locationBuying & sellingAppraisalsHours & visitsReviews & offersRecords

    PJ Coins & Metals

    Coin shop

    5152 Old French Rd

    1.8 mi from city center

    Call (814) 866-1253

    Sells

    Not verified

    Buys

    Call to confirm
    Not verified
    • Sat: 10 AM to 2 PM
    • Sun: Closed
    Weekly hours
    Mon
    Closed
    Tue
    10 AM to 5 PM
    Wed
    10 AM to 5 PM
    Thu
    10 AM to 5 PM
    Fri
    10 AM to 5 PM
    Sat
    10 AM to 2 PM
    Sun
    Closed

    4.8 / 5 on Google · 44 reviews

    Offer reports not analyzed

    • BBB NR

    Gem City Silver

    Coin shop

    160 W 8th St

    2.3 mi from city center

    Call (814) 384-8932

    Sells

    Not verified

    Buys

    Call to confirm
    Not verified
    • Sat: 10 AM to 2 PM
    • Sun: 12 to 4 PM
    Weekly hours
    Mon
    Closed
    Tue
    Closed
    Wed
    Closed
    Thu
    Closed
    Fri
    12 to 6 PM
    Sat
    10 AM to 2 PM
    Sun
    12 to 4 PM

    Google rating not verified

    Offer reports not analyzed

    No record verified

    Erie Gold Exchange

    Gold & silver buyer

    2256 W 8th St

    2.5 mi from city center

    Call (814) 878-0003

    Sells

    • Bullion
    • Jewelry

    Buys

    • Estates & inherited coins
    • Silver coins
    • Bullion bars & rounds
    • Gold jewelry & scrap
    • Platinum
    • Diamonds
    • Watches
    • Sports cards
    • Free appraisals
    • Estate / insurance appraisals
    • Sat: 9:30 AM to 4 PM
    • Sun: Closed
    Weekly hours
    Mon
    9:30 AM to 5 PM
    Tue
    9:30 AM to 5 PM
    Wed
    9:30 AM to 5 PM
    Thu
    9:30 AM to 5 PM
    Fri
    9:30 AM to 5 PM
    Sat
    9:30 AM to 4 PM
    Sun
    Closed

    4.9 / 5 on Google · 747 reviews

    14 fair / 0 low-offer mentions in 43 reviews analyzed

    • BBB B-

    Erie Gold Exchange

    Gold & silver buyer

    5034 Peach St

    0.8 mi from city center

    Call (814) 864-0028

    Sells

    • U.S. coins
    • Bullion
    • Jewelry

    Buys

    • Estates & inherited coins
    • Silver coins
    • Bullion bars & rounds
    • U.S. coins
    • Gold jewelry & scrap
    • Platinum
    • Diamonds
    • Watches
    • Sports cards
    • Free appraisals
    • Estate / insurance appraisals
    • Sat: 9:30am – 4pm
    • Sun: Closed
    Weekly hours
    Mon
    9:30am – 5pm
    Tue
    9:30am – 5pm
    Wed
    9:30am – 5pm
    Thu
    9:30am – 5pm
    Fri
    9:30am – 5pm
    Sat
    9:30am – 4pm
    Sun
    Closed

    4.9 / 5 on Google · 568 reviews

    Offer reports not analyzed

    • BBB B-

    Dempsey & Baxter

    Jeweler

    6032 Peach Street

    2.0 mi from city center

    Call (814) 825-7690

    Sells

    • U.S. coins
    • Bullion
    • Paper money
    • Jewelry

    Buys

    • U.S. coins
    Not verified
    • Sat: Closed
    • Sun: Closed
    Weekly hours
    Mon
    10 AM to 6 PM
    Tue
    10 AM to 6 PM
    Wed
    10 AM to 6 PM
    Thu
    10 AM to 6 PM
    Fri
    10 AM to 6 PM
    Sat
    Closed
    Sun
    Closed

    4.8 / 5 on Google · 267 reviews

    10 fair / 1 low-offer mentions in 54 reviews analyzed

    • BBB NR
    • NGC authorized
    • PCGS listed
    • PNG listed

    Aleks Cher Jewelers

    Jeweler

    4520 Peach St

    0.5 mi from city center

    Call (814) 860-7966

    Sells

    • Jewelry

    Buys

    • Gold coins
    • Silver coins
    • Paper money
    • Gold jewelry & scrap
    • Sterling silver
    • Platinum
    • Diamonds
    • Watches
    Not verified
    • Sat: 9 AM to 6 PM
    • Sun: 2 to 6 PM
    Weekly hours
    Mon
    9:30 AM to 6:30 PM
    Tue
    9:30 AM to 6:30 PM
    Wed
    9:30 AM to 6 PM
    Thu
    9:30 AM to 6:30 PM
    Fri
    9:30 AM to 6:30 PM
    Sat
    9 AM to 6 PM
    Sun
    2 to 6 PM

    4.1 / 5 on Google · 50 reviews

    Offer reports not analyzed

    • BBB NR

    Offer reports are counts from recent Google review samples, not a guarantee of what a shop will pay. Distance is from the city center.

    When can you sell?

    How many Erie shops are open, hour by hour

    Number of listed coin buyers open in each hour, by day
    Day8a9a10a11a12p1p2p3p4p5p6p7p
    Mon··44444442··
    Tue··55555552··
    Wed··55555552··
    Thu··55555552··
    Fri1166666663··
    Sat·155553311··
    Sun1111112211··

    2 are open on Sunday (Gem City Silver and Aleks Cher Jewelers). 1 stays open past 6 pm on a weekday (Aleks Cher Jewelers). Based on 6 shops with posted hours; hours change, so call ahead.

    From 97 recent reviews

    What Erie sellers bring in, and how it goes

    Most-mentioned items

    1. 1Gold jewelry & scrap3 reviews

    The experience, by the numbers

    • 23 reviewers: sold coins or metal
    • 7 reviewers: bought coins or bullion
    • 3 reviewers: got an appraisal
    • 35 praise: friendly, welcoming
    • 24 praise: fair offers / fair prices
    • 16 praise: knowledgeable
    • 14 praise: quick, efficient
    • Shops reply to 33% of reviews on average

    Counted from each shop's most recent public Google reviews. We tally topics; we don't republish reviews.

    Gold jewelry & scrap

    Where to sell gold in Erie

    4 places in Erie buy gold jewelry and scrap. Scrap is priced by weight and karat, so know your number first with the scrap gold calculator or today's gold price per gram, and get more than one offer.

    Buy gold & silver online. Compare live prices at APMEX and Bullion Exchanges, shipped insured to your door.

    BuyerTypeFair-offer mentionsScrap-gold reviewsGoogle
    Erie Gold ExchangeGold & silver buyer14 fair / 0 low mentions14.9★ (747)
    Dempsey & BaxterJeweler10 fair / 1 low mentions24.8★ (267)
    Erie Gold ExchangeGold & silver buyerNot enough dataNot analyzed4.9★ (568)
    Aleks Cher JewelersJewelerNot enough dataNot analyzed4.1★ (50)

    Pennsylvania law

    Selling coins in Erie: what Pennsylvania requires

    When you sell

    Pennsylvania's Precious Metal Sale Regulation Law excludes coins, ingots and bullion. ID and record requirements under that law apply to covered gold, silver and platinum items, such as jewelry and silverware; municipal requirements and shop policies may differ.

    Covered items must remain unaltered for five full working days after the purchase report is filed.

    When you buy

    Investment bullion is exempt from Pennsylvania sales and use tax, with no minimum purchase amount in section 204(65). The exemption covers refined precious metals valued for their metal content.

    Pennsylvania exempts investment coins from sales and use tax. These include U.S. and foreign numismatic coins with a market value above their nominal value; there is no minimum purchase amount in section 204(65).

    Who licenses dealers

    Dealers buying items covered by the Precious Metal Sale Regulation Law need an annual license from each county sheriff where they buy. Coins, ingots and bullion are excluded from that law's definition.

    Sources: Precious Metal Sale Regulation Law, Act 17 of 1984, sections 1-5 and 8 · 37 Pa. Code Chapter 501, Purchase and Sale of Precious Metals · Tax Reform Code, section 204(65). Not legal advice. Full Pennsylvania rules →

    Questions

    Selling coins in Erie: common questions

    How many coin shops are in Erie?

    We list 6 businesses in Erie that buy coins: 2 dedicated coin or bullion shops and 4 pawn shops, jewelers or gold buyers that also buy coins. 1 is NGC-authorized.

    Is there a coin club in Erie, PA?

    A Pennsylvania club directory lists the Erie Coin Club at Picasso's Restaurant, 24 N Park Row, Erie. Contact the club for its meeting schedule before you go.

    Where can I sell gold and coins in Erie?

    Erie Gold Exchange lists locations at 2256 W 8th St and 5034 Peach St and has operated since 1982. Dempsey & Baxter is at 6032 Peach St, PJ Coins & Metals is on Old French Rd, and Gem City Silver is on W 8th St. Call ahead to confirm what each buys.

    Which Erie coin shops offer free appraisals?

    Erie Gold Exchange and Erie Gold Exchange say on their websites that appraisals are free. Call ahead for large collections.

    Are any coin shops in Erie open on weekends?

    5 are open Saturdays (PJ Coins & Metals, Gem City Silver and Erie Gold Exchange) and 2 on Sundays (Gem City Silver and Aleks Cher Jewelers). Hours change, so check before you go.

    Do I need ID to sell coins in Erie?

    Pennsylvania's Precious Metal Sale Regulation Law excludes coins, ingots and bullion. ID and record requirements under that law apply to covered gold, silver and platinum items, such as jewelry and silverware; municipal requirements and shop policies may differ. Covered items must remain unaltered for five full working days after the purchase report is filed.

    Is there sales tax on gold and silver in Pennsylvania?

    Investment bullion is exempt from Pennsylvania sales and use tax, with no minimum purchase amount in section 204(65). The exemption covers refined precious metals valued for their metal content. Pennsylvania exempts investment coins from sales and use tax.

    Where can I buy gold and silver bullion in Erie?

    Erie Gold Exchange, Erie Gold Exchange and Dempsey & Baxter list bullion for sale on their websites. Stock and premiums change daily, so call for current prices and compare them with the live spot price.

    Where can I sell an inherited coin collection in Erie?

    Erie Gold Exchange and Erie Gold Exchange say they buy whole collections or estates. Don't clean the coins, keep them in their original holders, and get at least two offers for anything valuable.

    Sources: Pennsylvania coin clubs directory

    Coin shops in nearby cities

    All Pennsylvania cities →

    How this page is built: listings come from the NGC dealer locator, Google Maps and our own discovery; services come from each dealer's website; review topics are counted from each shop's most recent public Google reviews; BBB grades from bbb.org. No dealer pays to be listed or ranked. Methodology · Report a problem