GOLD —SILVER —

Melt values →
CoinShop Finder

Listing № 95334 · Cincinnati, OH

American Trading Company

Pawn shop in Cincinnati, Ohio · Est. 1982 (44 years)

3209 W Galbraith Rd, Cincinnati, OH 45239

Sells: U.S. coins, Bullion, Jewelry. Inventory categories & services

Buys: U.S. coins, Gold coins, Silver coins, Bullion bars & rounds. What they buy & services

Photos from American Trading Company's website

American Trading Company, pawn shop in Cincinnati, OhioPhoto 2 from American Trading Company's website

Photos from the dealer's website · Scroll for more

Good for: Scrap gold & jewelry · Graded coins & submissions

Hours listed below4.5on Google (103 reviews)Last review this month

American Trading Company is a pawn shop that also buys coins. For a whole collection, rare dates or graded coins, a dedicated coin shop will usually know the numismatic value better. Compare coin shops in Cincinnati →

§ 01

What American Trading Company buys and does

From American Trading Company's own website (5 pages read). Hover a ✓ to see their wording.

They buy

  • U.S. coins
  • Gold coins
  • Silver coins
  • Bullion bars & rounds
  • Proof & mint sets
  • Paper money
  • World coins
  • Ancient coins
  • Gold jewelry & scrap
  • Platinum
  • Diamonds
  • Watches

Services

  • Free appraisals
  • Grading submissions (PCGS, NGC)

Pricing & payment

In their words
“All of our prices are based of the Spot (Market) price of gold and silver.”
Pays sellers by
cash

Specialties: Silver dollars · Commemorative coins · Proof sets · Better U.S. single coins · Ancient coins · Scrap gold. Also sells: U.S. coins, Bullion, Jewelry.

§ 02

What recent customers report

We read the 60 most recent public Google reviews (Jun 2023 – Oct 2026) and counted what they mention. We don't republish reviews. Read them on Google ↗

Recent rating
4.3★
last 60 reviews
Reviews, past 12 months
25
busy shop
Owner replies
33%
5 of 10 one- or two-star
Customer-reported offers
84%
21 report fair offers; 4 report low offers, across 25 distinct reviews (reports can overlap)
Google reviews per month (newest 60 reviews)2024-12 → 2026-11
Reviews per month for American Trading Company2024-12: 02025-01: 22025-02: 12025-03: 02025-04: 12025-05: 02025-06: 22025-07: 12025-08: 12025-09: 32025-10: 02025-11: 12025-12: 12026-01: 32026-02: 12026-03: 12026-04: 22026-05: 22026-06: 42026-07: 42026-08: 42026-09: 12026-10: 12026-11: 0

Praised for

  • Friendly, welcoming29 of 54
  • Fair offers / fair prices21 of 54
  • Honest, trustworthy7 of 54
  • Knowledgeable7 of 54
  • Quick, efficient6 of 54
  • Good selection6 of 54

Complaints

  • Rude or dismissive6 of 54
  • Lowball offers4 of 54

What people brought in

  • Gold jewelry & scrap ×5
  • Gold coins ×2

Sold coins or metal (13) · Bought coins or bullion (4) · Got an appraisal (2)

§ 03

Trust record

Yelp rating via Bing Maps

3.5 / 5

8 reviews reported by Bing; separate from Google.

View on Bing Maps

Better Business Bureau

A+

Accredited since 2006 · 0 complaints closed in 3 years

BBB profile ↗

Credentials & licenses

  • CCE Member (Certified Coin Exchange dealer-to-dealer network) verify ↗
  • ICTA / NCBA Member (National Coin & Bullion Association) verify ↗
  • PCGS Authorized Dealer verify ↗
  • Federal Firearms License, pawnbroker in firearms (ATF) #4-31-061-02-8J-04439 · Active (on ATF's October 2026 licensee list) registry ↗
  • Ohio Pawnbroker license (PAWNBROKER) #PB.100642.000 · Active (on current DFI roster) registry ↗
  • ANA member (per their website)
  • ANA life member (per their website)

Track record online

Website first archived in 2008 (Internet Archive)

  • ◆Family owned since 1982 with two Cincinnati locations
  • ◆Authorized PCGS and NGC dealer that submits customers' coins for grading
  • ◆Licensed pawnbroker; offers loans at both locations
  • ◆A sheriff's deputy works at the store every day
  • ◆Sells guns through an in-store stock and an online partnership with Davidson's

Source: American Trading Company's website, read Oct 2026.

§ 04

Before you sell here

  1. 1

    Know your metal floor before you walk in.

    Gold is — and silver — an ounce right now. Our offer checker compares an offer with metal value and dated examples of published buy prices.

  2. 2

    Bring a government photo ID.

    Yes, bring identification. A licensed precious metals dealer must record your name, age, residence, driver's license number or other personal ID, and a short physical description (ORC 4728.06).

    A licensed dealer must keep each item it buys in Ohio until 5 days after the purchase (ORC 4728.09(A)).

    Source: ORC 4728.06 - Records (seller name, age, residence, ID number, physical description), ORC 4728.07 - Daily report of items received to police department · All Ohio rules

  3. 3

    Call ahead for anything bigger than a few coins.

    Ask whether the person who prices collections is in that day, and whether they pay by cash for larger amounts.

  4. 4

    Get a second offer.

    There are 7 other coin buyers within 10 miles. Compare them below. Read how to sell a coin collection first if this is your first time.

Questions to ask American Trading Company

We couldn't confirm these from public sources, so ask before you go:

  • What would you pay today for a 1 oz American Silver Eagle, and for $1 face value of pre-1965 silver? (Ask two shops the same question to compare.)
  • Do I need an appointment to sell a whole collection?

Buying, not selling?

Check online bullion prices before you pay a counter premium

Local shops are the best place to sell and to see coins in hand. When you're buying common bullion, the big online dealers often post tighter premiums over spot and ship insured to your door.

APMEX

One of the largest U.S. online bullion dealers, trading for 20+ years with 1M+ customers.

  • Gold & silver coins, bars and rounds
  • Live prices tied to spot
  • Insured shipping to your door
Shop gold at APMEX

Bullion Exchanges

Online precious-metals dealer with a deep catalog of bullion coins and bars.

  • Gold, silver & platinum bullion
  • Government-minted coins and private bars
  • Ships nationwide
Browse Bullion Exchanges

§ 05

Compare coin buyers near Cincinnati

How it compares in Cincinnati

  • Google reviews2nd of 9 · 103
  • Reviews in the past year1st of 8 · 25
  • Owner replies to reviews3rd of 8 · 33%
  • Hours open per week4th of 9 · 43 h

Among 9 coin buyers we list in Cincinnati. Ranks describe one measure each; none is a verdict.

If this shop isn't the right fit

DealerTypeDistanceGoogleCustomer-reported offersSat / Sun
American Trading Company (this shop)Pawn shop—4.5★ (103)84%Sat / –
COINS PLUSCincinnatiCoin shop17 mi4.4★ (110)67%Sat / –
Franklin Street Coin CompanyCincinnatiCoin shop9.6 mi4.3★ (91)82%– / –
Trubee's Vault (Hours by APPT ONLY)CincinnatiAppointment-only dealer12 mi4.9★ (57)—– / –
Main Street Coin - Hyde ParkCincinnatiCoin shop9.1 mi4.9★ (37)—Sat / –
ABC Coin CoCincinnatiCoin shop5.5 mi4.8★ (32)—Sat / –
Freedom Gold USACincinnatiBullion dealer9.2 mi5.0★ (6)—– / –
Springdale Jewelry & CoinSpringdaleCoin shop7.2 mi4.4★ (21)—– / –
Gold Rush ExchangeFairfieldGold & silver buyer8.7 mi4.5★ (53)—– / –
All coin shops in Cincinnati →

§ 06

American Trading Company: common questions

What does American Trading Company buy?

American Trading Company's website says it buys U.S. coins, gold coins, silver coins, bullion bars & rounds, proof & mint sets, paper money, world coins, ancient coins, gold jewelry & scrap, platinum, diamonds and watches.

Does American Trading Company sell coins or bullion?

Its website lists U.S. coins, bullion and jewelry for sale.

Does American Trading Company do coin appraisals?

Yes. Its website mentions free appraisals.

How does American Trading Company pay when you sell?

Its website lists cash.

What are American Trading Company's hours?

Mon 10am–5:30pm; Tue 10am–5:30pm; Wed 10am–5:30pm; Thu 10am–5:30pm; Fri 10am–5:30pm; Sat 10am–3:30pm; Sun closed. Hours change around holidays and coin shows, so call ahead.

Where is American Trading Company?

3209 W Galbraith Rd, Cincinnati, OH 45239. Phone: (513) 385-6789.

Answers come from American Trading Company's website, read Oct 2026, and its listed hours. Policies change; confirm by phone.