Coin shops & coin dealers in Cincinnati, Ohio
10 hand-verified dealers, ranked by review volume. See who's NGC-authorized, who buys collections, and who specializes in what — before you walk in.
10
Verified dealers
2
NGC-authorized
4.1★
Avg Google rating
420
Google reviews
Filter by what you need
COINS PLUS
225 E. 6TH ST SUITE 1
4.4(109)
(513) 621-1996
American Trading Company
3209 W Galbraith Rd
4.5(93)
(513) 385-6789
Franklin Street Coin Company
10742 Reading Rd
4.2(84)
(513) 554-0851
Trubee's Vault (Hours by APPT ONLY)
11427 Reed Hartman Hwy Ste 136
4.9(52)
(513) 805-5298
Main Street Coin - Hyde Park
3920 Edwards Rd
4.9(34)
(513) 731-1700
ABC Coin Co
6265 Glenway Ave
4.7(32)
(513) 661-1212
American Gold Buyers
451 Ohio Pike
4.1(15)
(513) 753-4653
Freedom Gold USA
300 E Business Way Suite 200
1.0(1)
(513) 957-3001
Freedom Gold USA - Selling Investment Grade Gold Bars, Bullions, Coins
201 E 5th St 9th Floor
(513) 957-2952
Hyde Park Rare Coin
3920 Edwards Rd
(513) 322-0560
Buying & selling coins in Cincinnati: common questions
How established is the coin market in Cincinnati?
Well established — this directory lists 10 hand-verified Cincinnati dealers, and the oldest, COINS PLUS, has been trading since 1972. American Trading Company (1982) and Main Street Coin in Hyde Park are other long-running names, so there's real depth for both buying and selling here.
Is there a coin club or coin show in Cincinnati?
Yes — the Cincinnati Numismatic Association meets monthly (usually the second Friday) and organizes the Greater Cincinnati Numismatic Exposition at the Sharonville Convention Center, a two-day show with roughly 180 dealer tables and free admission. It's the easiest place to compare many dealers at once.
Which Cincinnati coin shops have the best reputations?
COINS PLUS (established 1972) and American Trading Company (1982) both carry long track records and solid review histories, and Main Street Coin's Hyde Park location is highly rated. All Cincinnati dealers in this directory are verified by hand before listing.
Do Cincinnati dealers buy bullion and scrap gold?
Yes, most buy bullion and scrap alongside collectible coins. Because those offers follow the live spot price, check the day's price before selling — our gold and silver melt-value calculators give you a baseline so you can judge a Cincinnati offer fairly.